Aired on Valentine's Day, Naughty America sees the two best friends, Dylan (Chad) and Rico (Cindy), go after an African American male friend who is their best friend in school. After some embarrassing and erotic moments throughout the movie (most notably Dylan's suggestion that they give the "creampie" to each other), the two women are interrupted by a group of cops. Once the cops do, however, they don't find any evidence of wrongdoing-not until Rico and Dylan accidentally steal the pizza from the pizza delivery boy. The movie ends with a wild phone call in which Rico tells her friend that she likes black men; when the friend asks what "black man" she's referring to, she responds "Naughty America.".